Investment and Wealth Building
Myths About Investing in Gold: Why It's Impossible to Benefit from Surging Gold Prices in Nepal
by The Khatapana Guy
Apr 15, 2024 - 7 min read
Have you ever pondered why gold, often hailed as the ultimate refuge in times of financial uncertainty, attracts investors from every corner of the globe? It's not just about the luster and luxury—gold is a storied asset known for its ability to safeguard value when economies falter. This holds especially true in today's volatile world, where the uncertainties of pandemic aftershocks and geopolitical tensions drive more people towards this precious metal.
In Nepal, the intrigue surrounding gold investment grows as the global market sees unprecedented rises in prices. Recently, gold prices have been breaking records, with market values nearing a staggering Rs. 1,50,000 per tola and predictions hinting they might climb even higher. This surge is largely propelled by a robust international demand, notably with significant acquisitions by central banks like China’s, which are diversifying reserves away from the US dollar.
However, for the average Nepali investor, the situation presents a paradox. Despite the global uptrend in gold prices—which theoretically should open opportunities for substantial returns—the local market conditions paint a more complicated picture. The stringent regulations, high markups on purchases, and the added costs of buying and selling gold in Nepal create a formidable barrier. These obstacles often render the potential financial gains from gold investment elusive for common citizens.
In this article, we’ll debunk some prevalent myths about investing in gold in Nepal. We will dissect the economic forces driving global gold prices and examine why these do not necessarily translate into profitable investment opportunities for individual investors in Nepal. Let’s delve into the complexities of the gold market both locally and globally, and uncover why capitalizing on these "golden opportunities" might not be as feasible as it appears.
Debunking Common Myths
Investing in gold in Nepal is surrounded by myths that can often mislead potential investors about the realities of the market. Let's address these misconceptions and provide a clearer picture of what investing in gold really entails for the average person in Nepal.
Myth 1: Gold is Easily Accessible for Investment
- Contrary to popular belief, accessing gold for investment purposes in Nepal is not straightforward. The options are generally limited to buying physical gold in the form of jewelry or coins. However, these come with a significant markup—usually around 6 to 12% above the market price—which diminishes the potential for investment returns. The regulated nature of the market means that buying gold at true market prices is nearly impossible for retail investors.
Myth 2: Gold Investments Always Yield High Returns
- While it's true that gold prices have surged globally, the local scenario in Nepal complicates the profit equation. Due to the high initial costs, including markups and additional charges like making charges and 'jarti' (loss in marking), the actual purchase price of gold often significantly exceeds the market rate. This high entry cost means that gold needs to appreciate substantially just to break even, making quick and high returns a challenging prospect.
Myth 3: Gold is a Safe and Liquid Asset
- In many parts of the world, gold is lauded for its liquidity and safety as an investment. However, in Nepal, the liquidity of gold is a complex issue. When you decide to sell your gold, not only will you face deductions (around 2% less than the market price), but the layers of regulation can make the process slower and more cumbersome than anticipated. This challenges the notion of gold being a readily accessible emergency fund or quick cash resource.
These myths underscore a critical gap between the perception of gold investment and the on-the-ground reality faced by investors in Nepal. By understanding these key issues, potential investors can better navigate the complexities of the gold market in Nepal. In the next section, we'll explore the dynamics of gold pricing, shedding light on what drives these costs and how they impact your investment.
The Realities of Gold Pricing in Nepal
Understanding the dynamics behind gold pricing is essential for any investor, particularly in Nepal where the market operates under its own unique set of rules and influences. Here’s what you need to know about the factors driving gold prices in Nepal and how these impact your potential investment returns:
Global Market Influence:
- The price of gold in Nepal is heavily influenced by international markets. When global prices surge, as they have recently due to increased demand and significant purchases by countries like China, prices in Nepal tend to follow suit. However, this doesn't always translate into profit for local investors due to additional costs incurred within the country.
Local Markup and Additional Costs:
- The retail price of gold in Nepal includes various markups and additional charges that can significantly inflate the cost. When buying gold, consumers must pay not only a markup but also making charges and a 'jarti' fee, which together can increase the price by approximately 12% above the market value. These costs reduce the potential for profit unless the global gold prices increase substantially.
Price Volatility:
- Gold prices are subject to significant volatility based on international economic conditions, geopolitical tensions, and changes in demand. For instance, prices can fluctuate wildly from one day to the next; as noted, the market price might drop from Rs. 1,39,000 per tola to Rs. 1,36,000 per tola overnight. Such volatility can be a double-edged sword, offering opportunities for gains but also risks of substantial losses.
Regulatory Environment:
- The gold market in Nepal is tightly regulated, with restrictions on how and from whom gold can be bought. These regulations can impact the liquidity of gold as an investment and often complicate the buying and selling process.
Cost of Selling:
- When selling gold, the price received by the seller is typically about 2% less than the current market price. This deduction, along with the initial high purchase cost, means that the gold price needs to rise significantly for an investor to make a profit.
Understanding these pricing dynamics is crucial for anyone looking to invest in gold in Nepal. The high entry cost, combined with the regulatory environment and market volatility, makes it challenging to achieve quick or high returns on gold investments. In the next section, we will explore alternative investment strategies that might offer better outcomes for those looking to invest in gold without facing these hurdles.
Alternative Investment Strategies
For those in Nepal who find the direct purchase of physical gold prohibitive due to high costs and regulatory hurdles, the Government of Nepal and the Nepal Rastra Bank, the central bank of Nepal, should introduce alternative strategies to introduce gold as an investment options for Nepali citizens. Gold is merely considered as a cultural commodity and in an economy where the investment options are very limited, this could open a new avenue for the government as well as Nepali citizens. Here we discuss some of the alternatives that could be introduced in Nepal to offer potential ways to benefit from the value of gold without the need for physical ownership, which can be both costly and cumbersome.
Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs):
- Modeled after successful programs like India's Sovereign Gold Bonds, these are government securities denominated in grams of gold. They provide an alternative to holding physical gold, with the added benefits of earning interest and eliminating risks and costs associated with storage and security. Investors receive the market value of gold at the time of maturity, plus periodic interest, making SGBs a potentially more lucrative and hassle-free investment than physical gold.
Gold ETFs and Mutual Funds:
- Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) and mutual funds provide another avenue for investing in gold without physical possession. These funds invest in gold and its derivatives, offering a way to gain exposure to the gold market with the flexibility and ease of trading stocks. This can be particularly appealing for investors looking for liquidity and lower costs than those associated with physical gold.
Digital Gold:
- Digital gold platforms allow investors to buy, sell, and hold gold in digital form, with the assurance that the physical gold is securely stored by the service providers. This option offers the purity and security of physical gold without the logistical challenges of storing and safeguarding it yourself.
Diversification through Other Precious Metals:
- While gold has its allure, other precious metals like silver and platinum can also be viable investment alternatives. These metals sometimes outperform gold in certain market conditions and can provide a diversified investment portfolio, reducing overall risk.
Investing in Gold Mining Companies:
- Buying stocks of companies involved in gold mining can be another way to gain exposure to gold. While this involves different risks associated with company performance and sector-specific issues, it ties the investment's success to gold prices indirectly.
Each of these alternatives comes with its own set of risks and benefits, and choosing the right one will depend on individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon. By offering these options, the Government of Nepal may empower Nepali investors in finding more accessible paths to benefit from the value of gold, without navigating the myriad challenges presented by physical gold investment in the local market.
Empowering Nepali Investors Through Alternative Gold Investments
As we have explored throughout this article, the traditional pathways for investing in gold in Nepal are fraught with barriers that often deter the average investor from leveraging this precious metal's economic benefits. However, the introduction of innovative and accessible investment options could significantly alter the landscape for those interested in gold.
Advocating for Change:
- It's time for stakeholders, including financial institutions and government bodies, to reevaluate and potentially reform the regulatory frameworks that govern gold investment in Nepal. By aligning with successful models from other countries, such as India's Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) or the availability of Gold ETFs, Nepal could provide its citizens with safer, more lucrative gold investment opportunities.
Potential Benefits of Alternative Investments:
- Introducing alternative gold investment options like SGBs, Gold ETFs, and digital gold platforms could democratize access to gold investments, allowing more Nepalis to benefit from the gold market's dynamics without the prohibitive costs and risks of physical gold ownership. These alternatives not only offer practical investment solutions but also enhance financial inclusivity, allowing a broader segment of the population to participate in wealth accumulation activities.
Call to Action:
- For investors, the current scenario underscores the importance of staying informed and proactive. Engage with financial advisors, participate in discussions about financial reforms, and explore existing investment vehicles that might align with your financial goals.
- For policymakers, this is an opportunity to reconsider and innovate on investment options available to the public, ensuring that economic growth is inclusive and benefits a wider section of the society.
Looking Forward:
- The path to reforming gold investment in Nepal is undoubtedly complex and requires the collaboration of various sectors. However, the potential rewards—economic stability for individual investors, increased financial literacy, and a more robust economy—are well worth the effort.
By understanding the intricacies of the current gold investment framework and advocating for more accessible alternatives, Nepali investors and policymakers can work together to unlock the true potential of gold as a cornerstone of personal and national financial security. Let's look towards a future where investing in gold is not only possible for every Nepali but also a wise and rewarding financial strategy.